wsws.org

World Socialist Web Site
Strona głównaKolekcjeZakładkiHistoria

What are the origins of the war in Ukraine? Did the war begin in 2022 with a "first shot" fired by Russia?

The war in Ukraine did not begin in February 2022, and it cannot be explained by "who fired the first shot." That framing is itself a piece of NATO war propaganda, designed to present the conflict as an "unprovoked" act of aggression by a single man, Vladimir Putin, with no historical antecedents or economic motives. As David North wrote in his reply to Gideon Rachman of the Financial Times, "War is an event that arises from the complex interaction of social, economic and geopolitical processes and interests, operating on a global scale. The real cause of a war is rarely answered by determining who fired 'the first shot.'"

The real origins

The war's roots lie in the US-led drive to expand NATO eastward and absorb Ukraine into the Western military alliance, a process that began with the dissolution of the USSR in 1991 and accelerated sharply after 2014.

The decisive turning point was the US-backed coup of February 2014, which overthrew the elected government of President Viktor Yanukovych. Yanukovych had opposed measures to integrate Ukraine into an EU political association and trade pact that was itself a stepping-stone to NATO membership. The coup was financed by what US Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland boasted was "over $5 billion" in US funding, and was spearheaded by fascistic, ferociously anti-Russian organizations including Right Sector and the Svoboda Party.

As the WSWS noted at the time, the regime-change operation had "the intention of provoking a confrontation with Russia." It did exactly that. The coup threatened to hand control of Crimea — home of the Russian Black Sea Fleet at Sevastopol — to NATO, which would have given the US military dominance over the Black Sea. Russia responded by annexing Crimea following a referendum in which the overwhelming majority supported leaving Ukraine.

Meanwhile, the post-coup government of Petro Poroshenko carried out violence and repression against the Russian-speaking population of eastern Ukraine, leading to the deaths of more than 14,000 people between 2014 and 2022. War was already raging in the Donbass for eight years before the 2022 invasion.

The "unprovoked war" lie collapses

NATO's own Secretary-General, Jens Stoltenberg, inadvertently demolished the "unprovoked war" narrative when he admitted in 2023 that the war "didn't start in 2022. The war started in 2014." As Andre Damon documented in The narrative of the "unprovoked war" in Ukraine falls apart, this admission confirmed what the WSWS had argued from the outset: the conflict has a deep historical background, and the 2022 invasion was a desperate response to NATO's escalating efforts to bring Ukraine into its orbit.

The sequence is clear. While publicly claiming to support a ceasefire under the "Minsk Accords," the NATO powers systematically funneled billions of dollars in weaponry into Ukraine in preparation for a war aimed at reconquering eastern Ukraine and Crimea. In 2021, the Ukrainian government approved a strategy for the military reconquest of Crimea, codified in the US-Ukrainian Strategic Partnership of November 2021. Putin warned that if Ukraine joined NATO, the entire alliance would be pledged to support a war to reconquer Crimea — which would lead to nuclear war between NATO and Russia.

The class character of the war

The February 2022 invasion was the reaction of the Putin government, representing a faction of the Russian oligarchy, seeking to defend its interests while hoping to reach an accommodation with the imperialist powers. But the US and NATO are determined to realize through war the aims that motivated the 2014 coup: the military defeat, breakup, and conquest of Russia as a prelude to the subjugation of China.

This is why the ICFI insists that the working class has no side in this inter-state conflict. It is a war between rival capitalist powers — US imperialism on one side, the Russian oligarchy on the other — fought at the expense of the working class of all countries. The pseudo-left's defense of "Ukraine's right to self-defense" is a cover for arming a US proxy, and its talk of "Russian imperialism" is a justification for NATO. The answer is not to take sides in the war but to build the international unity of Russian, Ukrainian, and American workers against their own ruling classes, and to fight for the overthrow of capitalism — the only force that can end imperialist war.

Wygenerowano na podstawie tych źródeł

1
WSWS
2023: The global capitalist crisis and the growing offensive of the international working class
2
WSWS
NATO meets to plot next stage in Ukraine proxy war